Remembering why they're asked to serve
I was relieved to speak with a family member over the weekend who wears the uniform and has settled his family on a domestic American military installation after many years overseas. Given the tragic events of last week, I was anxious but he reassured me that everything was fine. He's always been good about calming fears.
On Veterans Day in the U.S. and Armistice Day elsewhere we give thanks to those who suit up and risk everything as we put this day in current context. But I'm an old-school history geek deeply affected by studying the events leading up to and following The Great War, especially after visiting the Imperial War Museum in London. If I had ever taught history -- only journalism topped that as a career choice -- this would have been my area of specialty.
Two of my favorite books about that era -- The Proud Tower by Barbara Tuchman and The Rites of Spring by Modris Eksteins -- masterfully explain the economic and cultural factors that led to the Victorian world being torn apart and for Modernism to emerge, for better and for worse.
What I admire the most about these authors is their unsentimental tough-mindedness not only of the time they depicted, but their continuing reminders of lessons that remain unlearned. Tuchman was particularly ruthless about this.
I'm not sure what Tuchman, who died in 1989, would make of our twin engagements in the Middle East. She thought Vietnam as foolhardy an involvement as I regard Iraq (and Afghanistan, increasingly). I will never agree with my relative -- who proudly served in Iraq -- about how the U.S. throws its military weight around the world.
But in this gem of a Vietnam-related essay, "The Citizen vs. the Military," Tuchman explains the unfortunate reality of why we'll always need to remember those who serve:
"It is not the nature of military man that accounts for war, but the nature of man. The soldier is merely one shape that nature takes. Aggression is part of us, as innate as eating or copulating. As a student of the human record, I can say with confidence that peace is not the norm."
Comments [0]